Archdiocese accuses Monsignor Benavente - KUAM.com-KUAM News: On Air. Online. On Demand.

Archdiocese accuses Monsignor Benavente

Posted: Updated:
 by Jolene Toves

Guam - Controversies within the Catholic Church continue as more accusations against Monsignor James Benevente have been made public by the Archdiocese of Agana.

Monsignor Benevente is accused of racking up nearly $1 million on credit card charges, cell phone payments, restaurants, air fare, stays at the Shangri-La Hotel in Manila and other five star hotels when he was rector of the Cathedral Basilica and director of the Catholic Cemeteries of the archdiocese. These accusations raised concern with the Concerned Catholics of Guam a group that was formed to investigate controversies within the Catholic Church.

Vice President Dave Sablan said, "As far as these issues in regards to credit card expenditures I am sure there are good reasons why the monsignor made those charges if they were made by him and this is something that the Concerned Catholics will probably look into."

The Archdiocese of Agana over the weekend issued a press release outlining some of the findings of an internal review in which "grave irregularities" were discovered involving the administration of the entities which were formerly administered by Monsignor James. According to the press release included in the questionable $1 million in expenses, Monsignor James is accused of gifting his close friends and family cemetery family crypts valued at $380,000. The archdiocese also calls out the monsignor for allegedly commingling funds and transferring funds between the Cathedral Basilica and Catholic Cemeteries thus making an audit impossible. The archdiocese was also critical of the monsignor for a $7 million loan for projects and the indebtedness its placed the archdiocese in.

However the CCOG contends otherwise, as Sablan said, "Some of the issue that were mentioned in the statement by the chancery in the finances of the Cathedral Basilica and how Monsignor James managed it have already been discredited number one the archbishop is the ultimate authority to sign off on any loan for the archdiocese and for that matter any parish they need to borrow money in a parish for example the archbishop needs to sign off on that otherwise loan cannot go through."

Sablan adds that the monsignor inherited just about all of the debt when he became rector. Although the monsignor did not answer our calls for comment, KUAM News has obtained a copy of an email he has sent to his close supporters disputing each and every allegation in the archdiocese press release. Monsignor James vehemently denies any wrongdoing and in some instances called some of the accusations "lies". For example claims now made by the archdiocese that the Catholic Cemeteries picked up a $13,000 tab to pay for Monsignor James 20th anniversary reception. The monsignor in his email to his supporters said that was not true and that it was paid for by his family and close friends. In terms of the credit card charges, the monsignor defended that he often times had to use his personal credit card to pay for the Cathedral Basilica's power bill as well as other supplies especially if he was ordering them from off island vendors. The monsignor points out that the cathedral does not have a credit card. As for the charges to stay in five-star hotels, he responds there was only one and confirms he did in fact stay at the Shangri-La and as a frequent customer he received a discounted rate. Matter of fact the archbishop himself has stayed at the hotel with him and that he always picks up the tab for the archbishop. In terms of the $7 million loan he questions why the archdiocese is making it look as if they did not approve the projects, considering that it had to be approved by all church bodies including the archbishop and current rector Monsignor David Quitugua. You may remember last year, Archbishop Anthony Apuron suddenly removed Monsignor James from his positions as rector of the cathedral and director of the Catholic Cemeteries citing financial mismanagement. Monsignor James denied the allegations.  
  • NEWS HEADLINESMore>>

  • Outback Steakhouse staffers feed homeless in Dededo

    Outback Steakhouse staffers feed homeless in Dededo

    On Monday our friends over at Outback Steakhouse volunteered their time and food to feed the homeless at the Dededo Mayor's Office. They grilled on site and fed over 70 individuals who came out to enjoy some good old fashioned barbecue, Outback style! Outback Steakhouse is closed temporarily for a major remodel and renovations. It is expected to re-open in early December. The renovation is part of their 20th Anniversary activities and while renovations are under way, the team have b...More >>
    On Monday our friends over at Outback Steakhouse volunteered their time and food to feed the homeless at the Dededo Mayor's Office. They grilled on site and fed over 70 individuals who came out to enjoy some good old fashioned barbecue, Outback style! Outback Steakhouse is closed temporarily for a major remodel and renovations. It is expected to re-open in early December. The renovation is part of their 20th Anniversary activities and while renovations are under way, the team have b...More >>
  • Mark Charfauros informed of slight delay in his trial

    Mark Charfauros informed of slight delay in his trial

    Will he make his comeback to the Guam Police Department? He'll need to have his case settled in the courts before the Civil Service Commission will entertain his termination appeal. Former police colonel Mark Charfauros appeared in court on Tuesday. There he was advised there would be a slight delay to his February trial. When asked if parties would reach a resolution instead of going to trial, defense attorney Randy Cunliffe stated "I doubt it." Trial is now scheduled ...More >>
    Will he make his comeback to the Guam Police Department? He'll need to have his case settled in the courts before the Civil Service Commission will entertain his termination appeal. Former police colonel Mark Charfauros appeared in court on Tuesday. There he was advised there would be a slight delay to his February trial. When asked if parties would reach a resolution instead of going to trial, defense attorney Randy Cunliffe stated "I doubt it." Trial is now scheduled ...More >>
  • Chief judge dismisses case against GEB members

    Chief judge dismisses case against GEB members

    It's official. In an order issued this week, Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood dismissed with prejudice the case against two Guam Education Board members in their individual capacities. They are Rosie Tainatongo and Jose Cruz, both of whom resolved their issues with Department of Education Superintendent Jon Fernandez. If you recall, Fernandez filed a $7 million lawsuit in the federal court after the board terminated his contract. No action was taken for the remaining GEB membe...More >>
    It's official. In an order issued this week, Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood dismissed with prejudice the case against two Guam Education Board members in their individual capacities. They are Rosie Tainatongo and Jose Cruz, both of whom resolved their issues with Department of Education Superintendent Jon Fernandez. If you recall, Fernandez filed a $7 million lawsuit in the federal court after the board terminated his contract. No action was taken for the remaining GEB membe...More >>
Powered by Frankly