Senators debate pros/cons of chemical castration - KUAM.com-KUAM News: On Air. Online. On Demand.

Senators debate pros/cons of chemical castration

Posted: Updated:

Some may consider chemical castration extreme, controversial or even necessary, and today lawmakers tackled the last bill on session agenda that would go after sex offenders who hurt those most vulnerable in our community.

Senator Brant McCreadie has called it a ruthless and relentless attempt, but is something that had to be done, noting, "Bill 99 is the first step into addressing Guam's rape problem." Introduced back in May, Bill 99 finally had its day on session floor and would establish a hormone or anti-androgen pilot treatment program for persons convicted of sex crimes. Essentially, it's the Chemical Castration for Sex Offenders Act.

"This problem is not going to solve itself," said the second-term Republican policymaker. "We are not going to wake up one morning and act if there's no problem and act as if we found a solution. We haven't."

The bill's intent is to impose treatment of chemical castration for convicted sex offenders who are eligible for parole or post-prison supervision. Drugs are administered are regular intervals to reduce the levels of testosterone in the body, in doing so reducing sexual drive and resulting in infertility. Similar castration laws are in effect in California and Florida, with more than a handful of other states who have experimented with similar legislation. "Is it a perfect solution? It's about as close as perfect as you're going to get," McCreadie argued.

Lawmakers like Senator Tom Ada, however, stated while he agrees with intent, the bill may provide a false sense of security. "Ww are going to parole a rapist because he has volunteered to be chemically castrated, as if suggesting, that's it, chemical castration, this guy is as about as safe as they can be, and that's not the case," he said.

Freshman senator Mary Torres also had concerns, arguing, "What I worry about this is when we impose this medical castration on as a condition of parole, when we impose it as a mandatory condition, what we're really doing, is we're imposing on their civil liberties. I believe the judicial system allows for people to rehabilitate."

Senator Nerissa Underwood meanwhile expressed her disappointment with the actual bill, stating it was crafted with a lack of care, and adding, "It's disappointing for a bill of this nature and with the intent to protect the victims, that there wasn't this type of attention to putting the package together."

McCreadie says in Europe, when used as a mandatory condition of parole, chemical castration decreases the occurrence of repeat offenses from 75% to 2%.

  • NEWS HEADLINESMore>>

  • Joint Region Marianas hosts Programmatic Agreement Workshop

    Joint Region Marianas hosts Programmatic Agreement Workshop

    Joint Region Marianas hosted the 6th Annual Programmatic Agreement Workshop on Thursday, at the Sen. Antonio M. Palomo Guam Museum and Education Facility. Collaboration and partnership among stakeholders and signatories were the common themes of the workshop. Du

    More >>

    Joint Region Marianas hosted the 6th Annual Programmatic Agreement Workshop on Thursday, at the Sen. Antonio M. Palomo Guam Museum and Education Facility. Collaboration and partnership among stakeholders and signatories were the common themes of the workshop. During the day-long event, the Navy team provided presentations on the progress made over the last year in a variety of significant areas. 

    More >>
  • Jury determines a mistrial in drug case

    Jury determines a mistrial in drug case

    Following closing arguments on Monday, the jury determined a mistrial in the drug case involving Raymond Martinez and Juanita Moser. The couple was on trial for conspiracy and possession of methamphetamine hydrochloride with the intent to distribute. It wMore >>
    Following closing arguments on Monday, the jury determined a mistrial in the drug case involving Raymond Martinez and Juanita Moser. The couple was on trial for conspiracy and possession of methamphetamine hydrochloride with the intent to distribute. It wMore >>
  • Lou & Josh official file paperwork for gubernatorial run

    Lou & Josh official file paperwork for gubernatorial run

    The Gubernatorial team of Lou Leon Guerrero and Josh Tenorio make it official. This afternoon they filed their paperwork for candidacy at the Guam Election Commission. Lou and Josh, are the third gubernatorial team to officially file. The team of former GMore >>
    The Gubernatorial team of Lou Leon Guerrero and Josh Tenorio make it official. This afternoon they filed their paperwork for candidacy at the Guam Election Commission. Lou and Josh, are the third gubernatorial team to officially file. The team of former GMore >>
Powered by Frankly