Jury can't reach unanimous decision in Agababa retrial - KUAM.com-KUAM News: On Air. Online. On Demand.

Jury can't reach unanimous decision in Agababa retrial

Posted: Updated:

Could we see yet another mistrial in the murder case of Allan Agababa, the man accused of killing his mother? The defense counsel motioned for that to happen after the jury returned to the courtroom today. But, it was immediately denied.

Jurors apparently are a difficult time working through the evidence and coming to a unanimous decision.

It appears jurors are losing hope at reaching a unanimous decision in retrial. Jurors have now spent a month in this case - that's three weeks of hearing testimony from both sides and one week of deliberations. Though they tried to tell the court they're undecided, judge Michael bordallo ordered they head back into deliberations and try again.

HIs Honor announced, "All of you are equally honest and conscientious jurors who have heard the same evidence. All of you share an equal desire to arrive at a verdict. Each of should ask yourself whether you should question the correctness of present position. I remind you that in your deliberations you are to consider the instructions you have been given to you as a whole. You should not single out any part of any instruction including this one and ignore the others. They are all equally important. You will now retire and continue your deliberations."

Jurors returned again at 5pm Friday and still hadn't reached a verdict. they were ordered to return Monday to continued deliberations.

Agababa is accused of aggravated murder for the death of his mother, 55-year-old Shelly Bernstein. He was tried for the crime three years ago, but jurors failed to reach a unanimous decision then, thus rendering a mistrial.

Although Guam's Chief Medical Examiner determined the manner of death a homicide, the defense disputed his findings stating prescription painkillers were involved and the manner of death was undetermined.

  • NEWS HEADLINESMore>>

  • Elderly man hit while crossing the road

    Elderly man hit while crossing the road

    An 81-year-old man is in critical condition at Naval Hospital after being hit by a car in Mangilao at around 7:00pm on Wednesday. Police spokesperson AJ Balajadia says the man was crossing from the median into the inner lane along Route 10 when was struck by a blue 2009 Toyota Yaris being driven by a 59-year-old man from Yona. The incident occurred by 24 Hour Laundry.  The victim was unconscious but still breathing while being transported to NRMC. Balajadia says Guam Highway Pa...More >>
    An 81-year-old man is in critical condition at Naval Hospital after being hit by a car in Mangilao at around 7:00pm on Wednesday. Police spokesperson AJ Balajadia says the man was crossing from the median into the inner lane along Route 10 when was struck by a blue 2009 Toyota Yaris being driven by a 59-year-old man from Yona. The incident occurred by 24 Hour Laundry.  The victim was unconscious but still breathing while being transported to NRMC. Balajadia says Guam Highway Pa...More >>
  • Committee makes recommendation for disciplinary action against Espaldon

    Committee makes recommendation for disciplinary action against Espaldon

    Will Senator Jim Espaldon be removed from his leadership positions? That's now for his colleagues to decide. Resolution 239 had been placed on the session agenda. It details the ethics committee's recommendation for disciplinary action against Espaldon. Last September, they found him in violation of the code of ethics and standards. Espaldon was under investigation for his alleged involvement in a generator deal between the Commonwealth Utilities Corp. in the Northern Mariana Islands...More >>
    Will Senator Jim Espaldon be removed from his leadership positions? That's now for his colleagues to decide. Resolution 239 had been placed on the session agenda. It details the ethics committee's recommendation for disciplinary action against Espaldon. Last September, they found him in violation of the code of ethics and standards. Espaldon was under investigation for his alleged involvement in a generator deal between the Commonwealth Utilities Corp. in the Northern Mariana Islands...More >>
  • Pink Ladies get funding for respiratory gear

    Pink Ladies get funding for respiratory gear

    It's Wednesday and the Pink Ladies are at it again. The United Airlines Employee Association of Guam presented a check of $5,000 to the Guam Memorial Hospital Volunteers Association. The amount will go towards hospital equipment, specifically a respiratory device that can be used on both children and adults. Errol Lee is the UAEG President and told KUAM News, "The employees association we felt a need, matter of fact one of the cornerstones of our organization is giving back to ...More >>
    It's Wednesday and the Pink Ladies are at it again. The United Airlines Employee Association of Guam presented a check of $5,000 to the Guam Memorial Hospital Volunteers Association. The amount will go towards hospital equipment, specifically a respiratory device that can be used on both children and adults. Errol Lee is the UAEG President and told KUAM News, "The employees association we felt a need, matter of fact one of the cornerstones of our organization is giving back to ...More >>
Powered by Frankly