Public Health won't accept same-sex marriage applications - KUAM.com-KUAM News: On Air. Online. On Demand.

Public Health won't accept same-sex marriage applications

Posted: Updated:

The Attorney General of Guam may have cleared the way for same-sex marriage on the island, but same gender couples will be met with a roadblock at the Department of Public Health.   

It appears that same-sex couples in Guam who thought they would be able to immediately apply for a marriage license will have to wait. While on Wednesday Attorney General Elizabeth Barrett-Anderson issued a legal opinion that cleared the way for same-sex couples to apply for a marriage license at the Department of Public Health. The agency's acting director, Leo Casil, will not be following her advice for now.

He said, "First, I would like to clarify that apparently that wasn't a legal opinion it was just an advisement letter for us to do. And, of course, my response would be that the position of the governor stands until such time as research has been accomplished everything remains on hold."

The attorney general's opinion was based on an October 2014 9th Circuit Court of Appeals decision in Latta v. Otter which held that state bans on marriages by persons of the same gender are unconstitutional. The AG added that Guam falls under the purview of the appellate court and hence Guam's laws on marriage are unenforceable earlier this week the governor was named as a defendant in a lawsuit filed in the District Court of Guam by same-sex couple Loretta Pangelinan and Kathleen Aguero. The couple is challenging Guam's marriage laws.

According to the AG's Office, she will not be representing Governor Eddie Calvo in the litigation. "I informed the governor that my position is that the lawsuit is indefensible," she explained.

It appears Adelup is waiting for an opinion from the US Supreme Court, which is hearing a case from the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals on the issue of marriage equality. However, according to Pangelinan and Aguero's attorney Bill Pesch, Guam does not fall under the 6th Circuit's jurisdictions, but rather the 9th Circuit, as argued by the attorney general in her opinion. "We totally agree with her that is it indefensible - that is our argument as it stands now with the 9th Circuit," Pesch affirmed. "Our argument is that this matter has been decided by the 9th Circuit; Guam falls under the 9th Circuit and therefore must comply with the 9th Circuit unless and until the Supreme Court decides otherwise."

Pesch says that they will proceed with the federal lawsuit to prove this point adding that the Governor's Office really should not take any

longer at this point to make up its mind on the issue. Pesh adds the governor's suggestion to send the matter to referendum is inappropriate stating that according to the Supreme Court, "Fundamental rights cannot be submitted to vote they depend on the outcome of no elections."
Because of the AG's legal opinion and Public Health's continued refusal to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, Aguero and Pangelinan's attorneys today filed an amended request for an expedited ruling. According to the filing, "This court should put an end to the unnecessary suffering, humiliation, stigma and anxieties attendant to Guam's purported marriage ban on plaintiffs and all committed same sex couples and their children who want and need the security of marriage.

"Every conceivable justification for same-sex marriage bans has been considered and rejected by the 9th Circuit in the Latta case, thus it would be a colossal waste of judicial resources to prolong this case.  The only remedy the plaintiffs argue is for swift justice through an expedited ruling."

  • NEWS HEADLINESMore>>

  • Outback Steakhouse staffers feed homeless in Dededo

    Outback Steakhouse staffers feed homeless in Dededo

    On Monday our friends over at Outback Steakhouse volunteered their time and food to feed the homeless at the Dededo Mayor's Office. They grilled on site and fed over 70 individuals who came out to enjoy some good old fashioned barbecue, Outback style! Outback Steakhouse is closed temporarily for a major remodel and renovations. It is expected to re-open in early December. The renovation is part of their 20th Anniversary activities and while renovations are under way, the team have b...More >>
    On Monday our friends over at Outback Steakhouse volunteered their time and food to feed the homeless at the Dededo Mayor's Office. They grilled on site and fed over 70 individuals who came out to enjoy some good old fashioned barbecue, Outback style! Outback Steakhouse is closed temporarily for a major remodel and renovations. It is expected to re-open in early December. The renovation is part of their 20th Anniversary activities and while renovations are under way, the team have b...More >>
  • Mark Charfauros informed of slight delay in his trial

    Mark Charfauros informed of slight delay in his trial

    Will he make his comeback to the Guam Police Department? He'll need to have his case settled in the courts before the Civil Service Commission will entertain his termination appeal. Former police colonel Mark Charfauros appeared in court on Tuesday. There he was advised there would be a slight delay to his February trial. When asked if parties would reach a resolution instead of going to trial, defense attorney Randy Cunliffe stated "I doubt it." Trial is now scheduled ...More >>
    Will he make his comeback to the Guam Police Department? He'll need to have his case settled in the courts before the Civil Service Commission will entertain his termination appeal. Former police colonel Mark Charfauros appeared in court on Tuesday. There he was advised there would be a slight delay to his February trial. When asked if parties would reach a resolution instead of going to trial, defense attorney Randy Cunliffe stated "I doubt it." Trial is now scheduled ...More >>
  • Chief judge dismisses case against GEB members

    Chief judge dismisses case against GEB members

    It's official. In an order issued this week, Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood dismissed with prejudice the case against two Guam Education Board members in their individual capacities. They are Rosie Tainatongo and Jose Cruz, both of whom resolved their issues with Department of Education Superintendent Jon Fernandez. If you recall, Fernandez filed a $7 million lawsuit in the federal court after the board terminated his contract. No action was taken for the remaining GEB membe...More >>
    It's official. In an order issued this week, Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood dismissed with prejudice the case against two Guam Education Board members in their individual capacities. They are Rosie Tainatongo and Jose Cruz, both of whom resolved their issues with Department of Education Superintendent Jon Fernandez. If you recall, Fernandez filed a $7 million lawsuit in the federal court after the board terminated his contract. No action was taken for the remaining GEB membe...More >>
Powered by Frankly