What happens when a defendant pleads insanity? - KUAM.com-KUAM News: On Air. Online. On Demand.

What happens when a defendant pleads insanity?

Posted: Updated:
 by Krystal Paco

Guam – "For many years now, there's been a shortage of psychiatrists on Guam. And so that means that the pool for forensic evaluators is very small," said Judiciary of Guam administrator of the courts Josh Tenorio. He said the shortage delayed the Chad DeSoto trial last year.

Desoto pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity and claimed the Devil compelled him to drive down a crowded Tumon sidewalk, crash his car, dart out and stab people at random. As a result, three were killed. Eleven others injured.

"So it's become an issue you saw it last year when we had the DeSoto trial. We had to fly in a psychiatric expert with expertise in forensic evaluations to conduct the evaluation with DeSoto and also to be the expert witness when it came to trial," Tenorio continued.

Although the courts once had an in-house clinician who specialized in forensic evaluations, that individual has since retired. Without the budget to hire a new one and lack of interest locally, Tenorio is hoping to grow the pool for case-by-case contracting. "So this is a big priority for us. We're trying to identify some professionals on island who we can train to do it. It is a challenge, but for the bridge, we've been trying to utilize resources that we do have available," he said.

Most recently defendant Yu Hua Han pleaded not guilty by reason of mental illness. Han is the woman accused of punching a 10-month-old baby in the face on New Year's Day before running away. Following her insanity plea, the court ordered she undergo a forensic evaluation within ten days. That however couldn't happen as the courts are at the mercy of the forensic evaluator's schedule.

"In that case," said Tenorio, "there has been an on island psychiatrist with the experience in forensic evaluation to conduct it. But of course, that's always driven by the schedule of the provider as opposed to the schedule we'd want to set with the court."  Tenorio assures KUAM News that Han is scheduled to undergo the evaluation in march so the case may move forward.

Meanwhile, it appears the same case is bringing to light another issue relative to mental health at the court level.

"And maybe one public policy area that needs to be looked at is the current statute for expungement - it limits the public's right to information on certain cases," he said.

It appears Han's priors were expunged as she was arrested in 2009 for stabbing a baby and the baby's father. According to the victim's family in this case, Han took the insanity plea and was deemed unfit to stand trial due to paranoid schizophrenia. The case is believed to be expunged as the courts could not confirm or deny this information. He summarized, "And so I think without getting outside of the gray line I think that probably by working with the judges and working with the legislature and trying to balance that with what the needs of the public, maybe there needs to be some reconsideration with that.

"Or at least reevaluating the information."
  • NEWS HEADLINESMore>>

  • Outback Steakhouse staffers feed homeless in Dededo

    Outback Steakhouse staffers feed homeless in Dededo

    On Monday our friends over at Outback Steakhouse volunteered their time and food to feed the homeless at the Dededo Mayor's Office. They grilled on site and fed over 70 individuals who came out to enjoy some good old fashioned barbecue, Outback style! Outback Steakhouse is closed temporarily for a major remodel and renovations. It is expected to re-open in early December. The renovation is part of their 20th Anniversary activities and while renovations are under way, the team have b...More >>
    On Monday our friends over at Outback Steakhouse volunteered their time and food to feed the homeless at the Dededo Mayor's Office. They grilled on site and fed over 70 individuals who came out to enjoy some good old fashioned barbecue, Outback style! Outback Steakhouse is closed temporarily for a major remodel and renovations. It is expected to re-open in early December. The renovation is part of their 20th Anniversary activities and while renovations are under way, the team have b...More >>
  • Mark Charfauros informed of slight delay in his trial

    Mark Charfauros informed of slight delay in his trial

    Will he make his comeback to the Guam Police Department? He'll need to have his case settled in the courts before the Civil Service Commission will entertain his termination appeal. Former police colonel Mark Charfauros appeared in court on Tuesday. There he was advised there would be a slight delay to his February trial. When asked if parties would reach a resolution instead of going to trial, defense attorney Randy Cunliffe stated "I doubt it." Trial is now scheduled ...More >>
    Will he make his comeback to the Guam Police Department? He'll need to have his case settled in the courts before the Civil Service Commission will entertain his termination appeal. Former police colonel Mark Charfauros appeared in court on Tuesday. There he was advised there would be a slight delay to his February trial. When asked if parties would reach a resolution instead of going to trial, defense attorney Randy Cunliffe stated "I doubt it." Trial is now scheduled ...More >>
  • Chief judge dismisses case against GEB members

    Chief judge dismisses case against GEB members

    It's official. In an order issued this week, Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood dismissed with prejudice the case against two Guam Education Board members in their individual capacities. They are Rosie Tainatongo and Jose Cruz, both of whom resolved their issues with Department of Education Superintendent Jon Fernandez. If you recall, Fernandez filed a $7 million lawsuit in the federal court after the board terminated his contract. No action was taken for the remaining GEB membe...More >>
    It's official. In an order issued this week, Chief Judge Frances Tydingco-Gatewood dismissed with prejudice the case against two Guam Education Board members in their individual capacities. They are Rosie Tainatongo and Jose Cruz, both of whom resolved their issues with Department of Education Superintendent Jon Fernandez. If you recall, Fernandez filed a $7 million lawsuit in the federal court after the board terminated his contract. No action was taken for the remaining GEB membe...More >>
Powered by Frankly