Closing arguments presented in Gargarita murder trial - KUAM.com-KUAM News: On Air. Online. On Demand.

Closing arguments presented in Gargarita murder trial

Posted: Updated:
 by Krystal Paco

Guam - Only Day Four of the Carl Gargarita trial and parties presented their closing arguments this afternoon.

Gargarita, who's charged with murdering Anthony Giralao behind a Tumon bar last year, contends it was self defense.

As prosecutor Gerald Henderson addressed jurors today, he argues the defendant, Carl Gargarita, continues to change his recollection of the events that unfolded in the early morning hours of June 15, 2013.

"How did Anthony die? Anthony died lying on the pavement behind a club at two a.m. in Tumon. He died as onlookers begged that the defendant let him go, to let him breathe," he said.

As we've been reporting, Anthony Giralao is the ex-husband of Irene Giralao. On the night of June 14, 2013, Irene had met with Carl Gararita for drinks where they later smoked weed and had sex in Irene's car. When Irene's phone rang, Gargarita answered making Irene upset prompting her to get up and leave. Gargarita and a friend followed after her to the back parking lot of the Old Traditions bar across the street. There Gargarita and Irene made two phone calls for her ride, one of which was to Anthony. Shortly after, Anthony came to the scene where the two men got into a fist fight that continued on the pavement when Gargarita put Anthony in a chokehold and reportedly stopped breathing. Anthony died later in a hospital.

Today, Henderson advised jurors to consider the defendant's story and how many times it changed from his initial interview with police to yesterday's testimony when Gargarita took the stand and demonstrated the headlock he used to hold Anthony down.

While defense argues that Gargarita acted out in self defense, Henderson argues Gargarita knew Anthony had already blacked out and that the additional thirty seconds he held onto Anthony's neck justifies his actions were reckless.

While prosecution questions the reliability of Gargarita's testimony, assistant public defender Peter Sablan asked jurors to consider that every person involved in that night's incident had a different version of that night's events, including eyewitness Kylie Herron who testified earlier in the trial. Herron, who didn't know either of the men, was an unbiased witness.

"You need to focus on the events. She saw the four runner speeding to where they were at. The car didn't even come to a full stop. Some guy comes running out of the car and starts charging at Carl (Gargarita) and starts throwing punches," he said.

Sablan asked jurors to remember how the fight unfolded as they decide whether or not Gargarita should be convicted for the murder of Anthony.

Jurors will begin deliberations on Monday.
  • NEWS HEADLINESMore>>

  • All Public Schools, GovGuam to Close by 1 p.m. Friday

    All Public Schools, GovGuam to Close by 1 p.m. Friday

    Acting Governor Joshua F. Tenorio, in consultation with Guam Homeland Security/Office of Civil Defense, the National Weather Service and the Guam Department of Education, has ordered that non-emergency Government of Guam services end at 1 p.m. Friday, FebMore >>
    Acting Governor Joshua F. Tenorio, in consultation with Guam Homeland Security/Office of Civil Defense, the National Weather Service and the Guam Department of Education, has ordered that non-emergency Government of Guam services end at 1 p.m. Friday, FebMore >>
  • GPD finds Finata Futuk Ludwig, wanted for domestic violence complaint

    GPD finds Finata Futuk Ludwig, wanted for domestic violence complaint

    A 34-year-old man wanted by Guam Police is captured in Hagatna. GPD spokesperson Sgt. Paul Tapao says their Domestic Assault Response Team along with Hagåtña Precinct Command Officers found Finata Futuk Ludwig. Authorities say Ludwig was wantMore >>
    A 34-year-old man wanted by Guam Police is captured in Hagatna. GPD spokesperson Sgt. Paul Tapao says their Domestic Assault Response Team along with Hagåtña Precinct Command Officers found Finata Futuk Ludwig. Authorities say Ludwig was wantMore >>
  • Task force formed to oversee permits

    Task force formed to oversee permits

    The Leon Guerrero-Tenorio Administration today announced the creation of the Governor's Task Force to Reform Government Permitting Procedures. The Task Force was created through an executive order and will be responsible for reviewing all government permiMore >>
    The Leon Guerrero-Tenorio Administration today announced the creation of the Governor's Task Force to Reform Government Permitting Procedures. The Task Force was created through an executive order and will be responsible for reviewing all government permiMore >>
Powered by Frankly